Talk:Clan Politics/@comment-5659637-20121031015632

I've a few things i'd like to change in the section 'Clan Tips' but before I do i'd like to run it past everyone by way of this comment.

To begin with, troops are donated for two purposes, to aid defense when a player is logged off and has no shield and attacking when a player is raiding. The most commonly requested troop is archers, yet is not mentioned above. Pekkas and dragons take up a huge amount of space, are very expensive and are really only relevant to high level players who are unlikely to be referencing this wiki in the first place (not a criticism, merely an observation of reality). Also, if using donated troops for unshielded defense, what purpose would a wall breaker have??

What does 'domestical clan progress are slow' mean???

There are plenty of clans out there that are looking to make top 50 and set idealistic rules and requirements that really never eventuate. Finding a loyal, respectful and socially entertaining clan is ultimately what will keep a player interested in playing Clash of Clans. Some of the tips above fall into the category of the idealistic clan rather than the realistic clan, ie. kicking lower players, promoting to elder if desperate, and in my opinion demonstrate bad clan practices rather than being good clan tips.

Also, promoting players to elder simply to get them in your clan can be potentially frought with disaster, elder should be earned and only given to trusted members of a clan.

Okay, that was really, really long winded!!! I love this wiki and enjoy making the small contributions to it that I do, so please don't take the above as criticism, I just wanted to know if anyone would seriously object to me making these amendments to the clan tips section. I'll do it if I have your support or simply leave it as is if I don't. :))